The dilemma is that if we base our judgment on performance, Chiles edges out Bărbosu and Voinea. The judges did indeed omit 0.1 points in the difficulty score, which they later corrected. On the other hand, if we base our judgment on a ‘by the book’ interpretation of the rules, the CAS decision is correct because the appeal came 4 seconds after the 1min deadline.
The dilemma is that if we base our judgment on performance, Chiles edges out Bărbosu and Voinea. The judges did indeed omit 0.1 points in the difficulty score, which they later corrected. On the other hand, if we base our judgment on a ‘by the book’ interpretation of the rules, the CAS decision is correct because the appeal came 4 seconds after the 1min deadline.