Genuinely asking because if not then he’s be the only MVP in league history to not make it. But when you think about the career he had after the injury, the fact we saw less than 4 years of him at what would we come to know as his best, and the credentials of other members, there’s definitely nuance and questions to it.
No. Wasn’t great for long enough, and he’s still alive. If his time was cut short due to death, maybe. Birth there are no special conditions that get him over the hump IMO.